Amazon SNS vs SignalR
Discover how Amazon SNS compares to SignalR, and understand which is right for your use case, based on dimensions such as core features, pricing, reliability, and scalability.
What is Amazon SNS?
AWS Simple Notification Service (SNS) is a fully managed notification service thats uses the Pub/Sub model to provide message delivery from publishers to subscribers.
Suitable for:
- Push notifications
- Apps with high message throughput
- Event-heavy apps
Not suitable for:
- Timed message delivery
- Ordered messages
- Precise retry control
Pros:
- Easy to use
- Instant message delivery
- Multi-protocol support
- Message filtering
Cons:
- No message persistence
- Limited scalling options
What is SignalR?
SignalR is an open-source library that simplifies adding real-time web functionality to apps. It is integrated into the ASP.NET Core web development stack and provides a mechanism for two-way remote procedure calls between client and server.
Suitable for:
- Apps that require high frequency updates from the server, like gaming, social networks, voting, auction, maps, and GPS apps.
- Dashboards and monitoring apps
- Collaborative apps
- Apps that require notifications
Not suitable for:
-Stateless applications -Apps with high scalability requirements -Apps with high throughput requirements
Pros:
- Open source
- Free to use
Cons:
- Self-hosted
- Complex to manage
Compare Amazon SNS and SignalR
Let’s compare Amazon SNS and SignalR, looking at key dimensions such as their core features, pricing, integrations, QoS, performance, and security and compliance.
Disclaimer:This comparison was created based on documentation and resources freely available online about Amazon SNS and SignalR. The content was last updated on 1 Aug 2024 for Amazon SNS and on 29 Jul 2024 for SignalR. Be sure to double-check everything before you make any decisions. If you do find anything incorrect or out of date, then please contact us.
Core features | |||
Pub/Sub messaging | Reduces communication code complexity, simplifying the process of building highly functional and architecturally complex realtime apps. | Amazon SNS | SignalR Partial The SignalR SDKs do not provide a topic abstraction out of the box, but they provide a "groups" abstraction which lets you implement something similar. Read more |
Chat capabilities | Accelerates the time to implement rich chat experiences with features such as read receipts, typing indicators, and more. | Amazon SNS Partial AWS SNS does not have in-built chat capabilities. It's primarily used for message delivery across HTTP/S, email, SMS, and Amazon SQS. You can use AWS Chatbot to enable chat in conjunction with SNS. | SignalR |
Collaboration capabilities | Enables you to quickly integrate realtime collaborative features like live cursors, member location, avatar stacks, and component locking. | Amazon SNS No | SignalR No |
State sync capabilities | Enables realtime data synchronization across devices and users, ensuring a cohesive and up-to-date user experience. | Amazon SNS Partial AWS SNS notifies on changes, but does not manage state synchronization directly. | SignalR No |
Presence | Maintaining a view of which users are connected, and their associated metadata, enables their online status to be updated in realtime. | Amazon SNS No | SignalR Yes Read more |
Occupancy | High-level metrics about the clients currently connected to a channel make it simple to show things such as connected user count, or display which channels are the most popular. | Amazon SNS No | SignalR No |
Message interactions | Enables interaction with previously-sent messages, facilitating the implementation of features like message reactions and threads. | Amazon SNS No | SignalR No |
Message history | Enables clients to catch up on missed messages when inactive, ensuring a user doesn’t miss any important messages. | Amazon SNS Yes AWS SNS allows topic subscribers to retrieve (or replay) the archived messages back to a subscribed endpoint. This can be done by with the AWS API, SDK, AWS CloudFormation, and AWS Management Console. This functionality is only available for application-to-application (A2A) FIFO topics. Read more | SignalR No |
Push notifications | Cross-platform push notifications make it possible to deliver important and timely messages to users even when they’re inactive. | Amazon SNS Yes AWS SNS specializes in delivering push notifications to mobile devices and other endpoints. | SignalR No Microsoft Azure Web PubSub has no native push notification functionality. Microsoft has a separate service for this - Azure Notification Hubs. Read more |
Message delta compression | Minimizes bandwidth and can reduce latency, particularly in scenarios where continuous updates are sent. | Amazon SNS No | SignalR No |
Programmatic management | Enables the automation of provisioning, management, and testing of service resources, simplifying integration with existing development workflows such as CI. | Amazon SNS Yes | SignalR No |
Pricing | |||
Free plan | With a free plan, you can test the service’s functionality and compatibility with your project before committing to a paid plan. | Amazon SNS No AWS SNS does not offer a free tier, but has a pay-as-you-go pricing model. | SignalR Yes Self-hosted and free. |
Pricing model | The pricing model should align with your project's expected load, usage patterns, and budget in order to be cost-effective and efficient. | Amazon SNS AWS SNS has a pay-as-you-go pricing model based on usage (number of requests and messages published). Read more | SignalR N/A (self-hosted) |
Integrations & interoperability | |||
SDKs | Supporting multiple languages and platforms offers greater flexibility when building cross-platform realtime apps. | Amazon SNS
| SignalR Client SDKs:
Server SDKs:
|
Supported realtime protocols | Support for multiple protocols provides the flexibility to choose a protocol that best suits your project’s requirements. | Amazon SNS
| SignalR
|
Serverless functions | Enables integration with third-party cloud providers by facilitating the execution of custom code against messages to perform business logic like on-the-fly translation. | Amazon SNS None natively; serverless functions are available through integration with AWS Lambda. | SignalR None. |
Streaming & queueing | Provides a dependable method to reroute messages from the service to third-party streams and queues for further processing. | Amazon SNS Partial Available through Amazon SQS. | SignalR No |
Observability services | Enables realtime monitoring and troubleshooting by offering insights into service behavior directly in your observability platform of choice. | Amazon SNS Partial AWS SNS provides an integration with Amazon CloudWatch for monitoring usage and metrics. | SignalR Partial SignalR is integrated with ASP.net Core metrics, and these can be reported to a monitoring system at regular intervals. Read more |
CI/CD tools | Makes it possible to provision and configure service infrastructure as part of a CI or CD pipeline, enabling repeatable and reliable deployments. | Amazon SNS Yes Supports:
| SignalR No Self-hosted, so you will have to implement your own. |
Quality of Service | |||
Scalability | Scalability is vital as it ensures the service can handle increased data load or users without compromising performance. | Amazon SNS No published metrics are available. | SignalR N/A (self-hosted) |
Guaranteed message delivery | Ensures messages are never lost during transmission, even in the presence of network disruptions. | Amazon SNS No | SignalR No |
Guaranteed message ordering | Maintains the sequence of messages as they were sent. This is particularly important in apps where the chronological order of messages is essential for meaningful communication. | Amazon SNS No | SignalR No |
Exactly-once message delivery | Guarantees that each message is processed exactly once, preventing data inconsistencies that can arise from duplicate processing or missing messages. | Amazon SNS No AWS SNS not support exactly-once delivery semantics out of the box. It ensures at least-once delivery, but does not guarantee exactly-once delivery. | SignalR No |
Performance & availability | |||
Uptime Guarantee | An uptime guarantee instills confidence in the reliability of the service and protects your business from the negative impacts of downtime. | Amazon SNS 99.9%. Read more | SignalR N/A |
Global edge network | By bringing servers (Points of Presence, or PoP) geographically closer to the devices of end users, and routing requests to the nearest PoP, global latency is reduced to a minimum. | Amazon SNS Yes | SignalR No |
Multi-region data replication (message durability) | By replicating data across multiple regions, the risk of data loss or downtime is greatly mitigated since if data is lost or a server fails in one region, the information can be retrieved from another. | Amazon SNS Partial AWS SNS supports message durability through integration with other AWS services for multi-region replication. | SignalR No |
No single point of failure or congestion | Having no single point of failure means a system is resilient and can continue to operate even if one part fails. Avoiding a single point of congestion ensures messages flow efficiently across the system and avoids bottlenecks that could lead to performance issues under load. | Amazon SNS Yes | SignalR No |
Latency | Low latency is crucial for realtime apps as it ensures swift and efficient data transmissions, providing a smoother and more responsive user experience. | Amazon SNS Unknown. | SignalR N/A (self-hosted) |
Security & compliance | |||
API key authentication | Simplifies the authentication code on trusted servers compared to requesting, managing, and refreshing tokens. | Amazon SNS Yes AWS SNS uses AWS IAM for managing API key authentication. | SignalR No |
Token-based authentication | Provides a means to securely authenticate user devices against your user management system. | Amazon SNS Yes AWS SNS uses the AWS STS (Security Token Service) for token-based authentication. | SignalR |
Single Sign-On (SSO) authentication | SSO streamlines login processes, boosts security by minimizing password use, and meets compliance needs for secure data access management. | Amazon SNS Yes AWS SNS supports Single Sign-On (SSO) through AWS IAM and AWS SSO. | SignalR |
Rules for permissions and operations | Provides control over which users can subscribe and publish to certain channels. | Amazon SNS Yes AWS SNS permissions and operations can be managed through AWS IAM policies. | SignalR Yes You can restrict access to hubs and hub methods to users matching specific authorization policies. Read more |
End-to-end encryption | Ensures that the data transmitted between the client and the API server remains confidential and secure while in transit. | Amazon SNS Yes | SignalR No You would need to implement this yourself. |
Encryption at rest | Ensures data stored by the service is secure and compliant, while also mitigating the risks of a data breach. | Amazon SNS Yes AWS SNS supports encryption at rest using AWS KMS (Key Management Service). | SignalR No |
Compliance | Compliance with regulations can impact your ability to meet legal obligations in your industry. | Amazon SNS
| SignalR N/A |
Alternatives to Amazon SNS and SignalR
Whilst both Amazon SNS and SignalR are worth considering as options for realtime experiences, they aren’t without their limitations. We suggest evaluating them against the following alternatives to make sure you find the right solution for your needs.
Alternatives to Amazon SNS
Google Cloud Pub/Sub is a scalable messaging service that can be used to send and receive messages from applications or services.
Azure Service Bus is a fully managed message service with message queues and Pub/Sub topics.
OneSignal is a customer engagement platform that offers push notifications, messages, and email sends for businesses to manage communication with their users.
Alternatives to SignalR
Socket.IO is a library that provides realtime, bi-directional communication between clients and servers. It allows the management of connections, sending and receiving messages, and more.
Microsoft Azure Web PubSub is a fully managed PubSub offering. It is available as part of Microsoft's Azure Cloud Computing platform.
Pusher is a first-generation pub/sub messaging service that provides bi-directional hosted APIs for adding realtime features to applications.
Discover how Amazon SNS and SignalR stack up against Ably
Ably is the definitive realtime experience platform of the internet. See how we compare to Amazon SNS and SignalR on key dimensions such as core features, pricing, integrations, QoS, performance, and security and compliance.
Try Ably for free to discover the benefits for yourself
Ably has built reliable realtime infrastructure so you don’t have to. On our free plan you benefit from:
- 6M monthly messages
- 200 concurrent channels
- 200 concurrent connections